| Dustin Ackley, 2B | Yunel Escobar, SS | |
| Brendan Ryan, SS | Kelly Johnson, 2B | |
| Ichiro Suzuki, RF | Jose Bautista, RF | |
| Justin Smoak, 1B | Adam Lind, 1B | |
| Jesus Montero, DH | Edwin Encarnacion, DH | |
| Alex Liddi, 3B | Eric Thames, LF | |
| Michael Saunders, CF | Brett Lawrie, 3B | |
| Miguel Olivo, C | Colby Rasmus, CF | |
| Casper Wells, LF | J.P. Arencibia, C |
Oh Ricky Romero, you're trying too hard