| Ichiro Suzuki, RF | Derek Jeter, SS | |
| Brendan Ryan, SS | Curtis Granderson, CF | |
| Dustin Ackley, 2B | Mark Teixeira, 1B | |
| Miguel Olivo, C | Robinson Cano, 2B | |
| Adam Kennedy, 3B | Nick Swisher, DH | |
| Mike Carp, DH | Russell Martin, C | |
| Justin Smoak, 1B | Andruw Jones, RF | |
| Franklin Gutierrez, CF | Eduardo Nunez, 3B | |
| Greg Halman, LF | Brett Gardner, LF |
If nothing else, at least the Mariners have the better shortstop.