I'm looking at this for the first time, just like you guys. Let's see what we've got.
|5||Brett Anderson||Oakland Athletics||5||1||3||31|
|8||Matt Wieters||Baltimore Orioles||-||1||3||6|
|9||Brad Bergesen||Baltimore Orioles||-||1||-||3|
|11||Travis Snider||Toronto Blue Jays||-||1||-||3|
Among AL starters with at least 100 IP, Brett Anderson posted the 9th-best FIP at 3.69, between Josh Beckett and John Lackey and behind zero rookies. His K/BB was excellent, he made 30 starts, and he threw a solid 175.1 innings. Somehow this was good enough to get him on all of nine ballots, while Rick Porcello came out better despite pitching like a pile of crap. Democracy! Don't know how Niemann finished above him either, but I guess there are still people who love them some W/L and ERA.
Kudos to Andrus and Bailey for being awesome, Andrus at defense and Bailey at everything. Again, hey, Anderson, but there's nothing wrong with rewarding guys who were legitimately great at what they did. Andrus is going to be a pest, and God help us if he learns how to hit.
No love for Rob Johnson or the Jakubaustrich.