AL Cy Young

21-game winner Bartolo Colon.

AL pitchers who were better than Colon this year, in order of FIP:

1. Johan Santana
   
2. John Lackey
   
3. Mark Buehrle
   
4. CC Sabathia
   
5. Kevin Millwood

AL pitchers who were better than Colon this year, in order of xFIP:

1. Johan Santana
   
2. Randy Johnson
   
3. John Lackey
   
4. Jake Westbrook
   
5. Dan Haren
   
6. CC Sabathia
   
7. Kevin Millwood
   
8. Mark Buehrle
   
9. David Wells
   
10. Jeremy Bonderman
    
11. Freddy Garcia

AL pitchers who were better than Colon this year, in order of ERA:

1. Kevin Millwood
   
2. Johan Santana
   
3. Mark Buehrle
   
4. Jarrod Washburn
   
5. John Lackey
   
6. Carlos Silva
   
7. Kenny Rogers

AL pitchers who were better than Colon this year, in order of wins:

1.