Matt Tuiasosopo Is Running Out Of Chances
It might surprise you to learn that Matt Tuiasosopo is only 24 years old. He feels like he should be 26 or 28 or something, and that's probably because he's beginning his eighth year as a member of the organization. Still, despite his relative youth and background as a prospect, he's posted a .540 OPS over his limited time in the big leagues with pretty mediocre defense, and at this point he doesn't seem to figure much in the team's big plans.
But that doesn't mean he doesn't figure at all, and Bob Condotta reported an interesting bit late yesterday evening:
But in what looms as a potential make-or-break season for the player ... the Mariners have asked Tuiasosopo to focus for the rest of the spring on left field and first base.
Tui, of course, has never been known for his defense, but he has been known for his versatility. That's the weird thing about defense; it's bad if you can't really play one position, but it's better if you can't really play many positions. Matt Tuiasosopo has played poor defense at many positions, and so he's been able to list versatility as a strength.
And now, at least for the time being, he's being asked to focus on first and left, and nothing around the rest of the infield. On the surface, that would seem to push him into a corner and limit his chances even further, but I'm not so sure.
The way I see it, the Mariners are going to run with a four-man bench. One of those bench guys will be a catcher - either Josh Bard or Adam Moore. One of those bench guys will be an infielder - probably Adam Kennedy. One of those bench guys will be an outfielder - probably Milton Bradley, or, in the event that Bradley beats out Michael Saunders in the left field competition, probably Ryan Langerhans or Gabe Gross.
That leaves one spot. With Ryan, Wilson, Kennedy, and Figgins, the M's will be covered at 2B/SS/3B. They'll be covered at catcher and they'll be covered in center. So what they'll probably want from the last guy is someone who can cover the corners and bring a bit of a bat. And that's where Tui could step in.
The job won't be handed to him. He'll be competing against a handful of others, possibly or probably including Matt Mangini, Mike Carp, Josh Wilson, and maybe Luis Rodriguez and the outfielders. But none of those guys is a standout favorite, giving Tui a real shot - particularly since Zduriencik seems to prefer a righty. This is his opportunity to show the team that he can swing the bat while serving as depth where the roster could use some depth.
He'll want to do that. He does still have an option left, meaning this isn't necessarily his last chance. But he's getting there, and if he reports to Tacoma, he runs the risk of getting buried. Based on the way things look right now, Tui has a job in front of him. He just has to earn it.
33 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
wouldnt Langerhans fit this bill too?
He would also bring the defensive abilities to cover the whole outfield as well as 1st. He’s shown in the past a good eye and has a penchant for timely dingers!
What's the deal with corn nuts?
by BaronVonBullshit on Mar 9, 2011 10:56 AM PST reply actions
Langerhans could fit
Based one Z’s quotes in Condotta’s article, though, the team seems to prefer a righty.
by Jeff Sullivan on Mar 9, 2011 11:02 AM PST up reply actions
The team's LH/RH mix is shaping up to be interesting and I'm sure will figure into this
Position – Handedness – player(s):
C – R/R/S – Olivo, Moore, Bard
1B – B – Smoak
2B – R/R/L/L – Ryan, Wilson, Kennedy, Ackley
3B – B – Figgins
SS – R – Wilson, Ryan, wilson
LF – L/B/L – Saunders, Bradley, Langerhans/Gross
CF – R – Gutierrez
RF – L – Ichiro (though not real platoon splits)
DH – L – Cust
So that’s:
3 spots in the lineup where you figure you’re primarily going to get lefties in there, LF, RF, and DH
2 spots are going to be manned by switch hitters who are thought to be better against righties, 3B and 1B
3 spots that will be primarily manned by righties, CF, SS, and C
1 spot that will be a mix of RH and LH depending on how the team shakes out, 2B
To me the Tui thing is basically a question of what the team thinks will happen with Bradley. The only thing Tui gives you defensively that Bradley doesn’t is the ability to cover 1B (and 3B/2B in a pinch) while Bradley is a much more capable OF.
I think the decision will come down to Langerhans/Gross (LH who can play CF) and Tui (RH to spell Cust, Saunders, Smoak) or Bradley (switch hitter who can play all OF positions and DH) plus someone like Luis Rodriguez. Bradley and Tui seem to do too many of the same things to make a well balanced bench if both are on the team.
Not that Tui would be an improvement over Smoak...
But I seem to remember reports of Smoak being much better from the left side of the plate. Maybe they want Tui there if they see the need to platoon Smoak to ease him in. Obviously I hope Smoak takes the job and runs with it, but having a righty bat to help Smoak/Saunders wouldn’t be a bad thing. This is all assuming that Tui figures it out at the plate, of course.
It doesn't make a great deal of sense to prevent Smoak from getting at bats in a possible area of weakness as he is counted on to be a cornerstone of the team.
Why hinder his development in order to get a bad bat into the lineup, especially when Tui doesn’t appear to have a future as a regular?
I don't want to hinder Smoaks' development any more than you.
I’m just thinking it may be a course of action the team may decide to take if Smoak experiences continued struggles against lefties, much like they seemed to do when handling Michael Saunders. Don’t get me wrong, the last thing I want is to see Smoak hurt in his development by being over-protected.
Yeah, didn't JT Snow start out as a switch-hitter, and then become a full time lefty?
Lefty thrower like Smoak, too
That picture confirms something I thought I've noticed at times in the past.
He still throws the ball like it’s a damn football.
Writer: ProBallNW.com
Fan: Seattle Mariners, Seattle Sounders FC, Liverpool
Twitter
by c_dowley on Mar 9, 2011 11:33 AM PST reply actions 5 recs
My first reaction was "Blegggghhhh!"
But now that I look I see that Tui has put up some pretty decent on base numbers. I think I still prefer Halman though; more power, better defender who can play center and not just left.
I have no confidence that Halman can be effective at MLB.
He’s a two true outcome player (HR and K) and you need that 3rd outcome (BB) to be effective when your HR to K ratio is that low.
He walked a lot *more* last year.
He still didn’t walk all that much. Still, the improvement was good to see.
Writer: ProBallNW.com
Fan: Seattle Mariners, Seattle Sounders FC, Liverpool
Twitter
True, but I have no confidence that Tui can be effective at MLB.
I’d rather have a good player than either of them, but it seems like Halman has a better shot at being good. Or at least he can play acceptable defense while not being good.
So you want Halman over Langerhans?
Tui beats the heck out of Halman as a 24th or 25th man on the roster when it comes to positional flexibility. So you have to believe that as a LF starter or 4th OF that Halman is better than Langerhans or another of the NRI OFs.
Which raises the irrelevant and unanswerable question...
Which is higher:
1) the percentage of non-Mariner MLB bench players that would be starters if they were on the M’s, or
2) the percentage of M’s bench players that would be starters in non-Mariners Triple-A organizations?
He's a hometown hero
- Because he’s a hometown hero, fans overlook that he’s pretty bad.
- He also can play many positions horribly.
- He’ll probably never be better than AAAA talent.
Matt Tuiasosopo is Willie Bloomquist.
Bloomquist was a pretty good defender
and Tui has something like power
by Bearskin Rugburn on Mar 9, 2011 3:11 PM PST up reply actions
I disagree.
Willie Bloomquist was and still is a bad defender. His career UZR is a -18.2.
Willie could steal bases.
"I've seen prison breaks with more organization and cooperation than this"
Not position adjusted.
Willie logged most of his innings at 2B/SS/3B/CF. Tui sucks while logging innings at 3B and LF
by Matthew on Mar 9, 2011 3:39 PM PST up reply actions 2 recs

by 


















