The Man With The Hardest And Easiest Job In The League
My girlfriend goes to grad school, and is gunning for a Ph. D in the chemistry field. My job isn't quite so demanding, and is seldom accompanied by the same level of stress, but it does require that I spend most of my time at or near a computer, since the timing of news is usually hard to predict.
As you can imagine, we don't get a lot of free time. It's hard enough for one of us to find the time to go do something, let alone both of us, simultaneously. Sometimes people will ask us if we want to go hang our or play pool or whatever, and we usually say we're too busy, and maybe next time. After a while, though, people get tired of hearing this excuse, and feel like they're being blown off. "Busy"? "Busy" isn't good enough.
Andy MacPhail's excuse is good enough.
"We’re going to start a mid-Atlantic Division," he joked. "Frankly in our view, Boston was a powerhouse and a force going into 2010 and suffered injuries that are almost inconceivable, and still had a pretty good year. Now, when they get Pedroia healthy and they get Youkilis healthy, they add Gonzalez and they add Crawford … ooof. Oooof."
… ooof. Oooof. "Oof" is the noise of the beaten and defeated. The hopeful man caught off guard doesn't say "oof". The man whose sad and doomed reality has just begun to dawn on him doesn't say "oof". The man who says "oof" is the man who's long since come to grips with his sad and doomed reality, the man who's resigned to facing a challenge so great it makes little difference should the challenge be made more difficult still.
Buddy 1: There's no way I'm going to be able to read 400 pages by tomorrow.
Buddy 2: 450 pages.
Buddy 1: oof
MacPhail's Orioles don't stand a chance. Mathematically, they do stand a chance, in that there is some combination of events that could take place and wrap up with the Orioles having won the division, but realistically, it's hopeless. It's hopeless now, it's been hopeless for years, and it will remain hopeless into the future. That's awful, and it's unfair, but I have to wonder if it isn't in some way liberating as well. There's no pressure. Where's the pressure? Pressure stems from expectations, and the Orioles don't have high expectations, because they can't have high expectations.
So, in a sense, MacPhail gets to go around and do whatever he wants. Sure, he has to make some effort to build an actual team, hence the trades for Mark Reynolds and J.J. Hardy, but in the end, it doesn't matter. He's protected by the fact that the Orioles are totally screwed, and he's further protected by the fact that the Orioles are so totally screwed that they end up on partial no-trade lists, and that high-profile free agents don't pay them attention. So what if Kevin Millwood struggles? So what if Cesar Izturis starts 142 games? "It's the best we could do," MacPhail can argue. And it might be true. And it doesn't matter.
Eventually, after the Orioles have finished in last place for enough years in a row, Andy MacPhail will be fired, citing disappointment and tradition and a need to shake things up. And MacPhail, I'm sure, is well aware of his inevitable fate. Until that day comes, I hope he's able to enjoy himself. Work doesn't get much harder, and work doesn't get much easier.
43 comments
|
2 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
This post makes me happy in ways that I've never felt
I’ve never imagined such hopelessness in a team, in an organization. Not only are they behind to the Red Sox in terms of talent, they’re certainly behind the Yankees, the Rays, and the Jays too. They are not terrible, and yet they are boned in every way.
I really hope Wieters works out for them.
I really didn’t understand how bad O’s fans have it until I went to a Yankees series at Camden. New Yorkers just absolutely take over the place. Add that to their division woes…ooof.
I had a discussion with someone today if it would be worth it for the Orioles to make a trade.
Namely, something like trading all of Wieters, Matusz, Jones, Arrieta, Britton, Erbe, Hobgood, etc to the Astros in order to swap divisions for, say, 10 years.
The Buffalo Bills of the AL East?
I am the master of my fate; I am the captain of my soul - Invictus
Also unfair
There is one division in baseball where, all else being equal, each team has a one in six chance to win the division. There is one division where, all else being equal, teams have a one in four chance.
The income disparity is the number one thing that needs fixing, but divisional realignment should also happen. Instead we’ll get an extra playoff team in each league, and baseball until Thanksgiving. Thanks, Bud!
My solution to both problems, by the way, is to add AL teams in NYC and in Portland, Oregon and realign to eight, four team divisions and kill the wild card.
Looking at a map
and the Nielsen numbers, a team in the Hartford/New Haven, Connecticut area would be a nice place to slot at a team to draw from both the NYC and Boston territories. They’re the 30th biggest TV market, which is small but puts them ahead of cities that already have teams, including Kansas City, Cincinnati and Milwaukee.
My question is how many people can you expect in NY City to realign to a new team?
How many Yankee/Met fans would be willing to give up their team for a new team? Seems tough.
Milton Bradley is my hero. R.I.P. Dave Niehaus
With a team smack between NYC and Boston
you’d be drawing fans from both teams’ territories, but not their home cities. This would serve to blunt their market share, and also have a good chance of surviving as a viable franchise of its own. A team in Hartford would instantly be the new hotness for local baseball fans (unlike a team in NYC which would have a harder time getting established).
Just a notion…but I think it’s easier to add a team to break up the markets of the big boys than to institute a salary cap or increased revenue sharing. Portland is the largest market with only one major sports franchise, so if MLB expands it should be there. To balance the league the next best place to add a team is where the biggest revenue teams need to be taken down a peg.
Not a snowballs chance in hell
Clearly you’ve never lived around here. The Orioles have a better chance of winning the World Series 18 straight times than a team in Connecticut stealing fans from the Red Sox or Yankees.
I would tend to agree with this.
If I lived somewhere between Seattle and Portland and have endured the M’s my whole life, I’m not going to become an instant Portland fan, just because Portland now has a team. I’ve got to deal with M’s baggage. Geography is not the answer to this one.
by TrustBaseball on Dec 9, 2010 11:42 PM PST up reply actions
It's not even that
People who live in places like Connecticut are forced to choose between the Red Sox and Yankees at a very young age. They tend to be even fiercer in their loyalties than those who live in Boston or NYC proper simply because they have to defend their choices all the time.
But new teams generate interest from many fans who had no real prior fanhood, too, plus new media attention, sponsors, etc.
Expansion probably won’t happen for the better part of a decade, at least, but I think enough owners will decide that New York needs a third team to restore competitive balance to the league that they will be able to override the Yankees and Mets’ objections. The A’s seem like they are destined for San Jose, and Charlotte would be a great spot for a second expansion team to go with the New York _. There’s a good article about it at Biz of Baseball.
Has Charlotte ever been able to support a pro franchise?
"Simply put, Dave Niehaus was why Marconi invented radio."
Having lived in both I can comfortably say that neither Hartford nor Portland could support a MLB team
Hartford’s a commuter city – nobody lives there. Nobody WANTS to live there, and nobody goes there for entertainment unless UConn is playing at the, uh, whatever they’re calling the Civic Center now. And Portland doesn’t have the business base that MLB looks for to buy luxury boxes and club seats – there’s Nike and Intel and then a really steep dropoff to a lot of mid-sized businesses who, even in a good economy, are reticent to spend big money on sports tickets. The Blazers have to fight every year to re-sell a majority of their luxury boxes, and an MLB team would find it much harder with that many more games on the schedule.
No chance in hell Hartford could support a major league franchise.
Hartford generally has a strong economic situation because its metropolitan area is a powerful insurance and high-tech manufacturing center. However, such a large percentage of Hartford’s population is its commuters who work in such places. Northern and Southern Hartford are some of the most dilapidated, economically challenged areas you will ever see. If the city had a decent sized market that actually showed interest in bringing aboard a major league franchise, that might be a different story. However, if you think this city has any chance of breaking up the Red Sox and Yankee fanbases in its current state, you’re dreaming. Take it from someone who can see the city from outside their window.
As a Mariner fan,
I would be completely opposed to this idea. The Mariner’s would lose a huge market, and dwindle our chances of ever winning a World Series. (Which at the age of 24, I’m starting to doubt will happen in my lifetime anyway.)
I've thought of solutions as well...
I think its worth thinking about shaking things up and realigning the division every so often. Have the Nationals and the Orioles change leagues every so often. Have them get dominated by other teams for once, just to make it a little more fun.
I love this post.
And I love the oof. Thank god we’re not in the East.
But if the A’s get money (they seem to be flaunting some this year—making a 19.1 million dollar bid for negotiation rights, etc.) they will be darn irritating.
In addition to the fucking sugar baby Angels and the creepy Rangers with their zillion dollar TV deal.
Well this certainly helps keep things in perspective.
I’ve been feeling rather glum about the M’s. The organization is so damaged by a decade of sucking on various fronts and our division rivals seem to have rather bright futures. Texas has a great farm, moneyed owners, serious current talent; Angels have a huge payroll and an aura of success; Oakland’s got Beane and his brand of small market team jiujitsu….
So yeah, 2011 is almost certainly a lost year, and 2012 may well be also. But at least winning the division is an attainable goal for us.
De Gutibus non disputandum est
by Bearskin Rugburn on Dec 9, 2010 4:57 PM PST reply actions
The Rangers talent is a few years away.
Most of their upper level prospects are already up, or were traded to us for Lee.
"Simply put, Dave Niehaus was why Marconi invented radio."
But they're loaded
As are the Angels. Once the A’s move to San Jose, their revenues will likely go up.
On the other hand, the M’s forturnes have only one way to go. We’ll never be as overmatched by the economics as Baltimore is. If Z’s bets on young talent pay off, we’ll compete.
Dude, skim.
If you’re really assigned 450 pages in one night you won’t be expected to read it word for word.
What class is he in?
What does he have to worry about the next day? A pop quiz? Surely he knew about this assignment coming up. A class discussion? Come on, he can hide out for an hour or whatever.
Well, you're not in grad school.
We’re totally expected to complete that amount of reading, if not more. Have you been in a seminar with 3 other grad students and one professor staring all of you down in fury? Hiding out becomes nearly impossible when there are 5 total people in the room expected to have a lively conversation about a reading for 3.5 hours.
I've been in classes with grad students who couldn't be troubled to read twenty pages in a week.
Which is one of the reasons why I won’t apply to grad school here.
"Ever tried? Ever failed? No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better." - Samuel Beckett Mariners Minors
by JY on Dec 9, 2010 6:44 PM PST up reply actions
I'm not in grad school...yet.
But seeing as how I’m a sociology major, I’m not expecting much of an uptick in difficulty.
by Liebkartoffel on Dec 9, 2010 6:51 PM PST up reply actions
Dude, have you never heard of cut and paste?
"Making hitmen legal would really help the unemployment rate."-Thingray
It depends on the class and prof
Aaron King, please pitch better.
McC Wiki - for all you newcomers out there.
Gee.. you'd think they would've tried to hire someone named MacWinner
by d0nkey on Dec 9, 2010 5:29 PM PST reply actions 6 recs
The important thing here is that when I started typing this same sentiment, I deleted it.
"Making hitmen legal would really help the unemployment rate."-Thingray
You know whats worse?
The Nationals just moved in. That takes the D.C. area right out of their revenue stream. You have to wonder what the owner of the Orioles said to the commissioner when he found out the plan.
If I were a die hard Orioles fan, I’m not sure what I would do…
The Orioles pretty much control the Nationals television rights/revenues.
That was part of the deal with Angelos when MLB wanted to move the Expos into DC. Mid-Atlantic Sports Network was created and is 90% owned by the Oroles. MLB paid Angelos $75 million for a 10% share. MASN is the network all the Nats games are broadcast on, so most of the revenue goes to the Orioles. The Nats ownership share will increase over the next few years, but it’s still a pretty good deal for the Orioles and a shitty one for the Nats. Linky.
No matter where you go, there you are.
With no floor, it's just sky diving.
Dawg! He put da team on his back!
by JAH on Dec 9, 2010 8:22 PM PST reply actions 6 recs
oriole fan/mariner fan lurker
I’m not sure it’s fair to say that the Orioles can never win the AL East. Before MacPhail arrived, the Orioles GMs would actually make Bavasi look Theo-esque in comparison. The Orioles were stuck in between never really trying to rebuild (outside of an ill-fated firesale facilitated by an overmatched 70 plus year old Syd Thrift in 2000), but never able to sign good free agents, choosing to go in between (throwing tons of money at guys who had no other alternatives). The Orioles farm system has long been a joke, with one horrible pick after another (recent history aside, hopefully). And if you can’t produce replacement level talent, you end up overpaying for mediocrity, handicapping yourself from making the purchases that you really need.
It might be true that the Orioles can’t win in their division. However, the Orioles just can’t get out of their own way. Terrible ownership, a dozen years of ineffective management, lackluster farm system have more to do with the failure of the organization than the Yankees. Or really there isn’t enough evidence to say either way (IMO).
But yeah, it kinda sucks being an Orioles fan. But what can you do?
(BTW, it would be nice if MLB reverted back to 2 divisions with 2 wild cards, making it possible for 3 AL East teams to make the playoffs.)
Librarians are hiding something

by 















