Who would you rather have this year, for only this year:

Player Alpha

a 45 year old, former 20 game winner with a 112 ERA+, 2:1 K:BB, a winning record, and 114 IP

OR

Player B

a 29 year old guy that has never gone more than 200 innings, with 81 so far this year, ERA+ of 108, a winning record, K:BB of 2:1, oh and you had to trade 5 guys to get him?

I think we all know who I am talking about, so please let me know.