Matt Garza available for trade
via Rotoworld:
According to the Minneapolis Star Tribune, "there are strong indications the Twins would be willing to move Matt Garza for a top young hitter."
The Twins previously passed on dealing Garza for the likes of Alfonso Soriano, but new general manager Bill Smith has made it clear that he's hunting for impact bats after the team struggled to score runs in 2007. Garza projects as a potential No. 2 starter, has yet to turn 24 years old and has a 4.47 ERA in 133 career innings, so he's likely to be a popular trade target.
Wlad and/or Clement for Garza? What do you guys think about the possibility of this, and is that enough to get him?
108 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Clement
Mauer
With all of the recent "young stud pitcher might be available" articles, I think GMs are simply floating names to gauge their players' worth with no real intent to trade them.
by G_ on Nov 8, 2007 9:32 AM PST up reply actions
Take a bigger perpsective
My point is that when thinking about trade situations, don't just consider whether what the Mariners (or any other team for that matter) offers is "good enough". Think about whether another team is likely to come up with something better.
In this case, don't you think another team would offer comparable talent that is already proven at the MLB level?
+++++++++
Which brings up a related issue. Most fans of teams consistently overestimate the value of their favorite team's prospects. Wlad and Clement are not worth as much as many fans think they are; they are still prospects, not proven MLB players.
Nor have Wlad and Clement even proven they are MLB ready. Both of them have checkered careers to this point, and there is ample reason to discount their 2007 campaigns as possible anomalies. It's not as if both players have shown the type of steady and continuing progress as they've advanced that makes an easy projection forward to MLB.
Great point
True
I think the real point is that trade speculation of any kind is a completely futile effort. You cannot be objective about it. It basically comes down to the whims of a small circle of people at the time. It's like trying to predict what I'll have for dinner next Tuesday.
There's pretty much no chance that's happening
Meatloaf is a great value
by G_ on Nov 8, 2007 11:04 AM PST up reply actions
Is that a team option, or a loaf option?
team option
Ketchup to be named later?
Meatloaf is the Joel Pineiro
Sure, it's cheaper than Applebees (consistent, boring: Carlos Silva), and it's less of a risk than sushi (AJ Burnett). But put the money aside for a moment: what are you really buying?
I was going to say meatloaf is the Kyle Lohse of dinner possibilities, but Kyle Lohse has priced himself out of meatloaf analogies.
You could go to Applebees,
It's an interesting analogy though, I wonder what other pitchers you could fit in there?
Intestinal cramps?
by pdb on Nov 8, 2007 1:30 PM PST up reply actions
I don't know if it's true for Applebees,
Like a Billy Beane minor league free agent,
by G_ on Nov 8, 2007 1:54 PM PST up reply actions
It's always helpful
Agree to disagree
Good-but-not-great in college, but at some point, the results have to be there. Cost is low, true, but that's because there simply isn't any production.
I don't even want it stashed for depth, not when you can go to the Japanese leagues and get Ramen for a fraction of the cost. Not when you can get the minor league free agents of the meat counter and at least have a SHOT at a good meal. Is there more risk that way? Sure, but to me meatloaf isn't a fallback, it's not a contingency plan - it's a white flag.
Hear Hear!
Oh, Pat Gillick, you are still livin' in the past
And really, isn't Ramen just an empty batting average?
by G_ on Nov 8, 2007 3:19 PM PST up reply actions
in between
I wouldn't keep meatloaf stashed in my fridge certainly, but I would keep it in my friends' fridge across the hall where I keep the rest of my filler foods and marinating meats that aren't ready yet for grilling.
Creativity and determination aren't free
And if meatloaf's advanced since 1980, so has ramen.
I'm not going to dispute that its value is tied up in empty batting average. That's tough, but fair. But give me a basically free empty average any day. It's the expensive empty averages that kill you, like the souffle that is Jose Vidro.
I think the other awesome, underpriced option is to go the Sean Green route and get something that wouldn't be good on its own, but see if your pitching instructors can't in essence deep fry it into palatability. Green was the ultimate in poorly textured vegetable matter in his Rockies days, but get him into the Fry Daddy of the M's minor league system, you've got yourself a league average (or better) samosa, all for basically nothing.
some people might say that we've annihilated this joke/metaphor, but I, obviously, disagree.
No, but they can be almost free
by G_ on Nov 8, 2007 3:52 PM PST up reply actions
another option
So, uh, which ballplayer
I think you were just straight-up revealing some truths about low cost food options, and I was thrown because there was no baseball in your suggestion.
Is Leo Mazzone the bbq sauce? Or is Adam Everett the bbq sauce?
Who the FUCK is this good bbq sauce, matthew?
tsk tsk
great BBQ sauce is defense to the meatloaf's bland pitching repertoire.
Your statement could've indicated
Hell, it could even be a stadium, spacious and wide as Texas itself, turning the rotting corpse of Hideo 'Meatloaf' Nomo into a serviceable starter in 2000.
I demand specificity.
ha
I have faith that Matthew will block it
I
1
!
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
!
So
He's also a fantastic singer
Plus, it's got Phil Rizzuto. What else could you want?
In the late 1990s
by G_ on Nov 8, 2007 11:29 AM PST up reply actions
Hey
You have to be wary about filets
I don't particularly enjoy
Filets
by Bearskin Rugburn on Nov 8, 2007 1:04 PM PST up reply actions
You have to watch out for cows
by chrisisasavage on Nov 8, 2007 3:45 PM PST up reply actions
Also
by chrisisasavage on Nov 8, 2007 3:46 PM PST up reply actions
Restaurants suck
I like my women like I like my coffee
b) weak and sweet
I can never decide which of those two I like better
by Bearskin Rugburn on Nov 8, 2007 1:06 PM PST up reply actions
Let me guess.
by pdb on Nov 8, 2007 1:23 PM PST up reply actions
married with children
by Bearskin Rugburn on Nov 8, 2007 1:31 PM PST up reply actions
I'm guessing your wife doesn't read this blog.
She is in the freezer
Well played.
c) strong but mellow when you add cream
d) five times a day
Since they have
Clement or Wlad
As someone above mentioned, you know there are ballclubs that will put together better packages than the M's can.
I can't find a picture of it
We'd never do it, but
The Twins need a new center fielder, and they need more offensive production from their OF. Plus he's cheap and will be under team control for six years.
There are few young position players who by themselves would be more valuable to the Twins. Another team might be able to put together a better package, but Jones for Garza would have to be alluring.
I'd rather have Wlad + Garza than Jones + say, an expensive Kyle Lohse.
Yeah I was gonna say
by Edgar for Pres on Nov 8, 2007 12:17 PM PST up reply actions
Side-splitting
Anyone else a fan of liver and onions?
I like the dish, but in baseball terms liver is more like Ibanez, a gritty veteran who can filter through the ups and down of the season. He's been through wars, and he's still plugging along.
And onions are a flavor all their own, not a spice that enhances the liver, rather compliments it. Kinda like, well, ...
I dunno, because now all I can think of is your poor livers. With all the beer talk/photos on this site, I am thinking your livers have gone through wars. And that all your livers look like Ibanez's bald pate. And thats weird.
by KC @ Lookout Landing on Nov 8, 2007 3:15 PM PST reply actions
Liver and onions
My dad used to eat liver and onions once a week, even until the year he died - he considered it a treat. He grew up during the Depression as the youngest of 7 kids, and his family didn't have any money, so liver was a treat back then as it was often the only meat they could get.
To this day, the smell of cooking liver makes me want to vomit.
by pdb on Nov 8, 2007 3:19 PM PST up reply actions
Disagree
by pdb on Nov 8, 2007 9:23 PM PST up reply actions
You're correct,
Not that it's a regular occurence, but last night I was out with my friends, and tonight I'm going to a concert.
pheh
by chrisisasavage on Nov 8, 2007 3:39 PM PST up reply actions
I'm working up to it.
it's a marathon not a sprint.
by pdb on Nov 8, 2007 3:44 PM PST up reply actions
I've found, as I get older
Not that that stops me, mind you. I just have to pick my spots better.
by pdb on Nov 8, 2007 3:44 PM PST up reply actions
I can still rally if necessary,
Used to be
These days, I go to the bar at 5, I stay till 11.30 or so, and usually the entire next day is spent on the couch battling, at various times, headaches, nausea, and odd twitches from drunk-sleep before going to bed at about 8pm and sleeping for 12 hours.
I love being older, I love getting older, but some of the mechanics of getting older really piss me off.
by pdb on Nov 8, 2007 3:49 PM PST up reply actions
I can go about three days in a row
Now I usually try to take a day off in between trips to the bar, but sometimes that doesn't happen because of my sports leagues or special events like Seahawks games, concerts and other stuff.
Getting older is great in many ways, but I do wish I was as indestructible as was when I was in my early twenties.
I won't do shots
At my bachelor party, that rule was suspended, and the number of people that kept buying me shots was ridiculous - they were all seizing their one opportunity, and good for them. It ain't happening again any time soon.
by pdb on Nov 8, 2007 4:05 PM PST up reply actions
My friends and I bet shots on everything.
The secret is to remember that the shots are bound to catch up to you, so you have to pcae yourself. But I completely understand that can be difficult after many beers. I almost made that mistake last night before a friend of mine said "slow down champ!" when I suggested another round.
agree
I wish I had friends who told me to slow down. They all thought it was funny.
^You know the scene in Super Troopers where he downs 4 whiskey shots in a row? That is literally how I would start my night back when I was a novice. Except I would do another 4 about 15 minutes later. I'm smarter now. Which is ironic when you think about alcohol and brain cells.
My rule is usually
I just don't drink shots
To me, shots always signified the desire to just get plastered ASAP. Leaving college and its peak and valley stress behind, I don't get that urge much anymore.
I suppose that's part of it,
Yes.
tell me about it
Friday 5pm: commence weekend with celebratory drink(ing).
Saturday 2am: stop drinking, pass out (somewhere)
Saturday 8am: wake up
Saturday 830am: finally figure out where I am
Saturday 9am: arrive at G&D for EPL matches that day
Saturday 915am: resume drinking
Saturday 4pm: matches done, stumble out of bar
Saturday 4-8pm: unsure of what happens
Saturday 8pm: dinner + drinks
Sunday 2am: stop drinking, pass out (somewhere)
Sunday 9am: wake up
Sunday 930am: arrive at bar for NFL games or back to G&D for good soccer matches.
Sunday 945am: resume drinking
it's rivaled some of my better stretches in college.
I always love going to the George
by pdb on Nov 8, 2007 3:52 PM PST up reply actions
George and Dragon
I can't believe I have never, NEVER thought to go there and watch EPL.
I havent had a drink
by KC @ Lookout Landing on Nov 8, 2007 3:55 PM PST reply actions
oddly enough
by pdb on Nov 8, 2007 4:00 PM PST up reply actions
I agree.
Takes guts to stop
by pdb on Nov 8, 2007 4:09 PM PST up reply actions
Exactly.
wow
How did you manage that?
by chrisisasavage on Nov 8, 2007 3:59 PM PST up reply actions
Well, its kinda fuzzy,
By the way, yarn fuzz stays in your throat for awhile.
by KC @ Lookout Landing on Nov 8, 2007 8:10 PM PST up reply actions
damn you all
sorry
How about
If I'm not having a complete brain-fart, I believe the Twins need a third baseman.
I'd really rather keep Clement, though.
While this thread obviously isn't about Garza
Rotoworld says the Twins are looking into Carlos Gomez.
I am against trading Clement
I am seriously all for keeping Jones and Clement. They are going to be productive players for the next while, it makes no sense to trade them while they are young AND cheap. Blockbuster only, anything that wasn't Bedard or Santana or Kazmir, would be punishable by death.
SO, how do we get better pitching then? Make everyone else (excluding Ichiro, Beltre, Yuni, JJ and Kenji, plus AJ, Clement,and of course Trui)
That still leaves Morrow, Wlad, Green, Sherrill, RRS, Lopez, Ibanez, Tui, Lowe, Chen, Jimerson,or Jesus Guzman.
To trade for 1 pitcher, I am sure there's a package out there. A package of Morrow, Wlad, and Sherrill would be pretty tasty for the right team and for the right guy, heck that's giving away alot.
Sign some rehab project (Colon or Wolf) or NBP star (Kuroda) and go for it. Save the 2 best prospects, they are too valuable to what our org needs right now, and really forever; a power hitting lefty (whether its 1B, DH, or C) and a power hitting, high range outfielder. Yes, we need pitching, but what these guys offer we can't easily replace.
Yes, I would love Jenkins for RF and you can't have enough power hitting lefties, but Jenkins isn't going to play for 7 more years and I don't always want to keep picking off the scrap heap for LHBs. Clement likely isn't fully ready yet, but the upside goes way beyond trading for Garza. Purely my opinion though.
I guess I am just excited for next year and hope for success out of the new guy(s).
You're kind of rambling
by Rollo Tomasi on Nov 9, 2007 11:20 AM PST up reply actions

by 










